Almost every mark in Topic 16 is a precise word in the right place. Pollination and fertilisation are two different events, and swapping them is the single commonest error in the whole syllabus. Fertilisation happens in the oviduct; implantation happens in the lining of the uterus. The two bloodstreams at the placenta never mix. A sperm has a flagellum. Germination needs water, oxygen and a suitable temperature — and not light. Haploid and diploid describe nuclei, not half-cells. HIV is the pathogen; AIDS is the condition it may lead to. Twelve traps, six data-led walkthroughs, six lookalike pairs, a concept map and ten full practice questions below, every one aimed at a place where a sensible-sounding sentence earns nothing at all.
Twelve traps that cost marks on Topic 16 challenge papers, spread across all six sub-topics. Every one is an answer that sounds right and that mark schemes refuse.
Six challenge-level questions with real data, worked through in the order you should actually think about them. Try each part before revealing the next step.
(a) Name the event happening on day 14 and give the evidence from the chart. [2] (b) Identify hormones P and Q, and give the evidence for Q. [3] (c) Identify hormones R and S and state where each is produced. [4] (d) Explain what happens to the lining of the uterus after day 24, and how the chart would look different if the egg cell had been fertilised. [4]
The shaded band covers roughly days 1–5, and the caption tells you day 1 is the first day of bleeding, so that band is menstruation — the lining of the uterus breaking down. The bottom track agrees: the lining is at its thinnest there. The dashed line at day 14 is ovulation, and the ovary track shows it directly: a follicle (V) enlarges up to day 14, an egg cell is released at the dashed line, and the structure left behind (W) appears after it. Every hormone can now be identified by where it sits relative to those two events.
Q is low and flat for the whole cycle except for one sudden, very sharp peak immediately before day 14, and ovulation happens at day 14. A hormone whose only activity is a spike that triggers an event is LH: LH causes ovulation. P is different — it is already fairly high at day 1, falls through the first week, shows a small bump near day 14 and rises again at the very end of the cycle. That is FSH, which stimulates a follicle in the ovary to develop, and which starts rising again at the end as the next cycle begins.
R climbs steadily through the first half of the cycle and peaks just before the LH spike. It is produced by the developing follicle (V) in the ovary, and it is oestrogen — look at the lining track underneath and you can see it thickening as R rises. S is flat until day 14 and then rises to a broad peak around day 21, which is exactly the life of the corpus luteum (W). S is progesterone. So: oestrogen from the follicle in the first half, progesterone from the corpus luteum in the second half, and both are produced in the ovary.
After about day 24 the corpus luteum breaks down, so the progesterone concentration falls. Progesterone is what maintains the thickened lining, so once it falls the lining can no longer be maintained and it breaks down — which is day 1 of the next cycle. If the egg cell had been fertilised and the embryo had implanted, the corpus luteum would have been maintained, S would have stayed high instead of falling, the lining track would have stayed thick, and there would be no shaded band at the end. Later in pregnancy the placenta takes over the production of progesterone.
(a) State the conclusion about light, naming the two sets that support it. [3] (b) Explain the result for set E. [3] (c) Set D was expected to give 0 %. Suggest why three seeds germinated. [2] (d) State one variable, not listed in the table, that must be kept the same in all five sets, and explain why. [2]
Compare the rows, not the numbers. A and B have the same water, the same oxygen and the same temperature; the only difference is light against dark. They germinated 92 % and 90 % — a difference of 2 seeds in 100, which is well within the ordinary variation between two batches of seeds. So light is not required for germination. Naming the pair is worth as much as the conclusion, because it is the evidence.
At 4 °C the seeds had water and oxygen, so nothing was missing — the process was simply too slow. Germination depends on enzymes, which digest the stored food in the seed. At a low temperature the molecules have less kinetic energy, so there are fewer successful collisions between enzyme and substrate and the rate of reaction is very low. Note the wording carefully: the enzymes are not denatured by cold — that happens at high temperature — so those seeds would still germinate if they were warmed up.
Boiling and an oil layer reduce the oxygen but do not guarantee that none is left; a little oxygen could have dissolved back in before the oil was poured, or been trapped as a bubble against a seed. Three seeds in a hundred is the sort of number you get from an incomplete removal, not from a different biology. An alternative worth a mark: for a very short time a seed can survive on anaerobic respiration, which releases far less energy, so a very few seeds might just begin to germinate before stopping.
Good answers: the same species and variety of seed, and seeds of the same age — old seeds germinate poorly, so a difference between sets could be caused by the seeds rather than by the conditions. Also the same volume of water, the same number of seeds (already 100 each, which is why percentages can be compared), and the same time allowed. Never write “keep everything the same”: name one variable and give its consequence.
(a) State the direction of net movement of oxygen, glucose and urea, and name the process responsible. [4] (b) The amino acid figures are the other way round. Explain how amino acids can still move into the fetal blood. [3] (c) Explain why the placenta must have a large surface area and a thin barrier. [2] (d) State one substance in the mother’s blood that can cross the placenta and harm the fetus. [1]
Oxygen: 95 in the mother, 40 in the fetal blood — higher in the mother, so the net movement is from the mother to the fetus. Glucose: 90 against 60 — also mother to fetus. Urea: 25 against 45 — higher in the fetal blood, so the net movement is from the fetus to the mother, which is exactly what you would expect for an excretory product the fetus cannot deal with itself. All three are moving down a concentration gradient, so the process is diffusion.
Amino acids are already more concentrated in the fetal blood, so moving more of them into the fetus means moving them against the concentration gradient. Diffusion cannot do that. The process is active transport: protein carriers in the cell membranes of the placenta move the amino acids from a lower to a higher concentration, using energy released by respiration. That is why the cells of the placenta contain many mitochondria — a detail worth adding, because it is evidence rather than assertion.
A large surface area means more diffusion can happen at the same time, so the rate of exchange is high enough to supply a growing fetus. A thin barrier gives a short diffusion distance, so exchange is rapid. The placenta is folded into villi for exactly the reason the small intestine and the lung are — and the fetal capillaries lie very close to the mother’s blood spaces without the two ever mixing. If the bloodstreams mixed, none of this structure would be necessary, which is the quickest way to remember that they do not.
Some antibodies cross from the mother, which is useful — they give the newborn temporary passive immunity. But some pathogens and toxins cross too and can damage the fetus: HIV and rubella virus are examples of pathogens, and nicotine, alcohol and some drugs are examples of toxins. It is the price of a surface built for exchange, and it is a stated part of the syllabus rather than an aside.
(a) Name the type of reproduction used for group R and state what this means about the offspring. [2] (b) Explain the year 2 result for group R. [3] (c) Explain why group Q lost more plants than group P. [3] (d) Suggest why the grower might still choose method R next year. [2]
Group R was produced from side shoots of a single plant: one parent, no gametes and no fusion of nuclei, so this is asexual reproduction and every plant in group R is genetically identical to the parent and to each other. Groups P and Q both came from seeds, so a pollen nucleus fused with an ovule nucleus in each: both are sexual reproduction, and both give offspring that are genetically different. The bagging in Q forced self-pollination; it did not turn Q into asexual reproduction.
Because every plant in R is genetically identical, they all have the same resistance, or the same lack of resistance, to the new disease. If the pathogen can infect one of them it can infect all of them, so almost the whole group was killed. Nothing about the disease was unusual — the vulnerability came from the absence of variation in the group, which is the standard disadvantage of asexual reproduction both in the wild and in crop production.
In group P the pollen came from a different plant of the same species, so the offspring combine genetic material from two parents and show more variation. In group Q the pollen came from the same plant, so all the genetic material came from one individual and there is less variation — though still some, because Q is sexual reproduction. More variation means a greater chance that some plants happen to be resistant and survive, which is exactly what the numbers show: 22 lost from P against 61 from Q.
R gave the highest yield, 4.1 kg per plant, and because the plants are genetically identical to a plant already known to be good, the grower knows in advance that every plant will have that desirable feature — the crop is uniform and ripens together, which makes harvesting and selling easier. It is also faster and does not depend on pollinators. The disadvantage is the one shown in year 2, and a sensible grower manages it by not planting only one variety.
Fig. 6.1 and Fig. 6.2 show the two human gametes. (a) Name the cells A to D in Fig. 6.1 and the structures E to H in Fig. 6.2. [4] (b) Man X has plenty of sperm and almost none of them move. Suggest which structures are likely to be faulty and explain your answer. [3] (c) Only 3 % of Z’s sperm have a normal structure. Explain, referring to Fig. 6.2, why this reduces the chance of fertilisation. [3] (d) Compare the numbers of male and female gametes produced, and explain the difference. [2]
Fig. 6.1 is drawn to one scale, and the difference in size is the point: a human egg cell is about 0.1 mm across, while a sperm is a few micrometres wide. So the large cell is the egg cell: A is its jelly coat, B is the energy stores in its cytoplasm and C is the egg cell nucleus. D is the sperm cell. In the enlarged Fig. 6.2, E is the acrosome at the tip, F is the sperm nucleus, G is the mitochondria in the middle piece and H is the flagellum. Use the word flagellum, never “tail”.
Movement needs two things, so there are two sensible answers and both earn credit. Either the flagellum is faulty, so the cell has no working structure to beat and propel itself with. Or the mitochondria are faulty or too few, so aerobic respiration cannot release enough energy for the flagellum to beat. Note what the data rule out: the count is 71 million per cm³, well above the reference value, so this is not a problem of numbers. When a question gives you three measurements and only one is abnormal, the explanation has to be about that one.
Z’s sperm are numerous and they swim, so they will reach the egg cell. But a sperm still has to get through the jelly coat, and that is the job of the enzymes in the acrosome (E), which digest a path through it so the sperm nucleus can enter and fuse with the nucleus of the egg cell. If only 3 % of the cells are structurally normal, most have a defective acrosome or head, so far fewer sperm are capable of penetrating the jelly coat and fertilisation is much less likely.
Size: the egg cell is much larger. Structure: the egg cell has a jelly coat and large energy stores; the sperm has a flagellum, many mitochondria and an acrosome. Motility: the sperm is motile and swims; the egg cell is not motile and is moved along the oviduct. Numbers: sperm are produced in enormous numbers, tens of millions in a single release, while typically one egg cell is released each month. The reason is that the great majority of sperm never reach the egg cell — producing millions makes it likely that at least one does.
(a) Describe the two trends shown after 2008. [3] (b) A student concludes that the programme failed, because the percentage of adults living with HIV went up. Evaluate that conclusion. [3] (c) Suggest three measures the programme could have included to reduce the number of new infections. [3] (d) Explain why prescribing antibiotics to everyone would not have appeared anywhere in the programme. [2]
New infections rose to a peak of about 150 thousand in 2008 and then fell steeply to about 35 thousand by 2020, a fall of roughly 77 %. The percentage of adults living with HIV rose throughout, from about 5.0 % in 2000 to about 9.5 % in 2020, but the rise became much slower after 2008 — it is nearly level from 2012 onwards. Always check which axis a line belongs to before quoting a number; the two lines here use different scales and different units.
The orange line counts new infections in one year. The blue line counts everyone currently living with HIV, as a percentage of the age group. Those are not the same measurement, and they can move in opposite directions. If people who are infected are treated and live much longer, the number of people living with HIV rises even while fewer people are being infected. A rising blue line combined with a falling orange line is exactly what a successful programme looks like, and mistaking one for the other is the trap the question is built on.
An evaluation that only attacks scores badly. The student is right that the percentage living with HIV rose, and right that a lot of people in country Z are still infected, so the problem has not gone away. The student is wrong to use that figure as a measure of success, because the measurement that shows whether transmission is being prevented is the number of new infections — and that fell sharply after 2008. Note too that the graph shows a correlation in time: the fall began when the programme began, but the graph alone cannot prove the programme caused it.
HIV is transmitted by sexual contact, by infected blood (shared needles, or transfused blood that has not been screened) and from an infected mother to her child across the placenta, during birth or in breast milk. So the measures follow the routes: education about how it is transmitted; testing and contact tracing, so infected people know and can be treated; antiviral drug treatment, which reduces the amount of virus and makes transmission far less likely; screening all donated blood; providing clean needles and not sharing them; and treating infected pregnant women to protect the child.
Six pairs that look almost identical and have different answers. In this topic the distinction is nearly always where the marks live.
Click each node. The whole topic is four stories: one parent or two, the plant route from anther to seedling, the human route from gamete to fetus, and what happens when a pathogen uses that same route.
Six answers of the kind that read fluently and score badly. Find the fault before you reveal it.
Ten Cambridge-style challenge questions, each drawing on more than one sub-topic. Write your answer first, then reveal the model answer and the examiner’s notes.
(a) Name the structures A, B, D, F and G, and state what the brackets J and K represent. [4] (b) State the function of B and the function of D. [2] (c) This flower is insect-pollinated. State one feature visible in Fig. 1.1 that would be different in a wind-pollinated flower, and explain why. [1]
(a) Name the structures A, B, C and E. [2] (b) Name the event that happens in region X and the event that happens in region Y, and state how many days apart they usually are. [3] (c) Describe what happens to the zygote between X and Y. [2] (d) Name the male structures in which sperm are produced and along which they travel to the urethra, and state why the testes are held outside the main body cavity. [2]
(a) Name the structures P, Q, R and S in Fig. 7.1. [2] (b) State the function of R and S. [2] (c) In Fig. 7.2, the green arrows and the orange arrows show substances moving in opposite directions. Name two substances travelling with the green arrows and two travelling with the orange arrows. [2] (d) Explain how substances are exchanged at V and W without the two bloodstreams mixing. [2] (e) State the source of progesterone in the later part of pregnancy. [1]