The laboratory prepares mixtures of genuine powder and cornflour and tests each with the same volume of iodine solution.
| cornflour added / % | 0 | 5 | 10 | 20 | 40 |
|---|
| colour with iodine | orange-brown | pale blue-grey | blue | dark blue-black | dark blue-black |
The suspect batch gave a
blue colour.
(i) Estimate the percentage of cornflour in the suspect batch. [1]
(ii) Give two reasons why this estimate should be treated with caution. [2]
(iii) Suggest one way of obtaining a more trustworthy figure. [1]
Model Answer — 1c
(i) about 10% cornflour [1]
(ii) the colour is judged by eye, so the comparison is subjective and depends on the lighting [1]
(ii) above about 20% the colour stops changing, so the scale cannot distinguish high percentages, and the steps between the known mixtures are wide [1]
(iii) measure the colour with a colorimeter and read the percentage from a calibration graph, or repeat the comparison with mixtures at smaller intervals [1]
⚠ If you missed marks here: Notice the ceiling in the data: 20% and 40% look identical, so this scale is only usable at the low end — spotting that saturation is the mark that separates strong answers. The other caution is the eye: a colour chart is a semi-quantitative tool, and semi-quantitative means an estimate, not a measurement.